Human cloning – A Number

(Warning: contains plot spoilers!) How would cloned sons react to one another and how would they interact with their father? These are some of the issues raised by Caryl Churchill’s play A Number.  The story consists of five conversations, snapshots into an otherwise untold narrative.  Each scene features the same two actors, father and son, but the younger is actually representing three different sons – one conceived naturally and two that are his clones. 

In the first conversation, the father (Salter) is talking with Bernard, a son he has raised on his own.  Bernard, aged 35, is aware that he is a clone and that other genetically identical individuals exist.  He is cross-examining his father about what happened to his older self and is informed (incorrectly, as we shall see) that he died in a car crash with the boy’s mother.  Bernard despairs that “I’m just a copy”, but Salter stresses he is “the one”, the reason why the cloning was originally done and that the scientists carrying out the process had deceived him by making other additional copies.

In the second conversation, it transpires that the first son (also called Bernard) is very much alive but was grossly neglected as a child, particularly after the death of his mother.  He knows that a clone exists and has been brought up by Salter in his rightful place, “you had a copy of me made from a ‘painless scrape’ and… you had the rest of me thrown away”.

In conversation three, the clone Bernard is talking with his father.  He has now met his older original and aware of the jealous rage of his neglected sibling, intends to flee from him.  As such, this conversation is partly goodbye and partly an appeal to know the truth before he goes – if his brother clearly hasn’t died in a car crash, then what came of his mother who was supposed to have died in the same incident?  Salter tells him what, we must assume, is the real version – she threw herself under a train.

The fourth conversation is between father and original son. He has tracked down and slain the other Bernard, the chosen clone.  What, asks the father, about me?  What about the other clones – will they all be killed?  The fifth and final conversation reveals the answer; Bernard has killed himself instead.  Salter is now talking with Michael, one of the additional twenty clones that were made without his permission.  Michael asks various questions – does his father intend to meet with all of the clones?  Do I look like the original son?  The striking feature of this exchange however is the ordinariness of Michael’s life – his job (maths teacher) and his family (married with three children). Were it not for the unusual circumstances of his birth he might have been an anybody.

Originally an hour-long stage play, a 45 minute radio version starring Michael Gambon and Daniel Craig was transmitted on BBC7 in November 2006 (TRILT identifier 005D6A7D).  A script is published by Theatre Communications Group (ISBN-10 1559362251; ISBN-13 978-1559362252).

How could I see A Number being used in a teaching setting?  A thoughtful class of A level students (that is 17 or 18 year old, for those not familiar with the UK system) studying English might discuss the place of cloning in fiction, perhaps drawing comparison with Never Let Me Go and/or The Island.  In truth, however, although cloning is central to A Number, the play offers more insights into relationships than either the ethics or science of human cloning.  As Matt Cheney has commented on his Mumpsimus blog “Churchill doesn’t write a play “about” cloning, but rather a play that includes cloning, a play that couldn’t exist without cloning.” The question of genetic determinism, nature v nurture might be raised; the three sons may be genetically identical, but their diverse upbringing has clearly led to dramatic differences in their personalities.  Having said that, the reality is that, although thought provoking, A Number is probably not the first choice for introducing science students to the arguments surrounding the ethics and/or technology of human cloning. 

One Response to Human cloning – A Number

  1. A television version of A Number was transmitted on the BBC this week. At the time of writing it can still be seen (but not recorded) using the iPlayer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: